The View From Inside · 04

“Unstable”

When emotional precision is mistaken for instability.

← All essays
A yellow flower unfolding in sunlight among many shades of green

People often mistake emotional precision for instability.

I’ve started to realize that many people seem to experience emotions in broad categories, while I experience them in shades.

Maybe they have six.

I have forty-eight.

Disappointment is not the same as sadness. Betrayal is not simply anger. Grief is not a single feeling but a palette: love, disbelief, tenderness, rage, and the quiet collapse of a future you had already begun to imagine.

When I name an emotion, I try to name the shade accurately.

That does not make me dramatic.

It means I can see more than one color.

For most of my life, I believed this was a strength—a kind of emotional intelligence leaders are told to cultivate.

But apparently, it only “counts” when expressed in a language everyone recognizes.

My ability to name an emotion does not mean I am consumed by it. Often, it means the opposite. I can stand inside a feeling and still observe it clearly enough to understand exactly what it is.

And yet, the more precisely I describe what is happening inside me, the more likely someone is to label me “unstable.”

I once had a conversation with a boss about a promotion I had been promised.

It didn’t happen.

I had been patient. I had done the work. The explanation I was given didn’t align with the facts, and I could no longer see a path forward that made sense.

So I said the news was devastating and that I didn’t know where to go from here.

To me, the meaning was obvious:

Something important had been taken away, and I didn’t know what it meant for my future in the organization.

That was it.

No hidden message.

No crisis.

But that wasn’t what she heard.

She told me she was worried. She said she had never heard someone use language the way I did and wondered whether she needed to call Human Resources.

And just like that, the conversation was no longer about the broken promise.

It was about the words I used to describe the broken promise.

Great, I thought. Now my boss thinks I’m unstable.

Let’s pull HR in.

I wasn’t falling apart.

I was hurt, angry, and trying to understand what this meant for my career.

Those are three different things.

And I knew the difference.

This is where the translation breaks down.

I experience emotions deeply, but I also experience them with clarity. I can be inside a feeling and still observe it. I can understand where it came from, what it touches, and why it matters.

Intensity and control are not opposites inside me.

I can feel devastated without being destroyed.

I can feel lost in one part of my life without being lost everywhere.

I can say I don’t know where to go from here without implying danger.

There is no hidden message.

I am telling you where I am.

But people often hear emotional language as volume.

I use it as resolution.

The more precise I become, the louder I seem.

What feels like clarity inside me becomes intensity outside me.

What feels like emotional accuracy becomes evidence that I am overreacting.

They mistake articulation for dysregulation.

And once that happens, there is no graceful way out.

If I explain more, I’m escalating.

If I object, I’m defensive.

If being labeled “unstable” upsets me, that reaction becomes proof that the label was correct.

The harder I try to return the conversation to what I actually meant, the farther it moves away from me.

I never learned to soften it.

I didn’t know there was anything to soften.

Only now, writing these essays, do I understand why so many bosses looked at me the way they did. 😳

I thought I was describing my experience with precision.

They thought something alarming was happening.

Apparently, I’ve spent my life speaking in forty-eight shades to people who may hear only six—and then wondering how something so clear inside me became something so concerning outside me.

The tragedy was never that I felt too deeply.

Or that I lacked control.

Or that my emotional world contained too many colors.

The tragedy was that the world kept collapsing all that color into a single word:

“Unstable.”

A note from the other side

Did this feel familiar?

If something in this essay resonated with you, you’re welcome to leave a reflection. Your message will remain private unless you give permission for it to be shared.